Question

The question below consists of a statement followed by two arguments numbered I and
II. You have to decide which of the arguments is a 'strong' argument and which is a 'weak' argument. Statement: Should a developing municipality phase out its traditional, centralized underground water reservoir network to completely transition to a regional rainwater harvesting and localized graywater filtration network? Arguments:
I. No, because rainwater harvesting and graywater recovery are heavily reliant on highly seasonal precipitation patterns, which could fail to provide a consistent, baseline volume of water during prolonged dry spells or droughts.
II. Yes, because migrating entirely to localized harvesting and recycling systems will significantly decrease the depletion of deep natural aquifers and dramatically lower the municipal energy footprint required to pump water across long distances.

A Only argument I is strong
B Only argument II is strong
C Either I or II is strong
D Neither I nor II is strong
E Both I and II are strong
Practice Next

More Strong and Weak Argument Questions

Hey! Ask a query