Question
Article 5–11 (Part II) contain citizenship provisions
at commencement. Which of the following accurately describes the transitional effect of Article 5 at the commencement of the Constitution?Solution
Article 5 of the Constitution forms part of Part II (Citizenship) and was intended as a onetime, transitional provision applicable at the commencement of the Constitution on 26 January 1950. It granted Indian citizenship primarily on the basis of domicile in the territory of India, coupled with conditions such as birth in India, parentage, or ordinary residence for a prescribed period. The framers deliberately avoided a purely racial or religious basis for citizenship and instead adopted a territorial–domiciliary principle, consistent with constitutional secularism. Articles 6 and 7 separately dealt with migrants to and from Pakistan, indicating that Article 5 did not cover all migration scenarios. In State Trading Corporation v. CTO (1963), the Supreme Court emphasized that Part II provisions were meant to settle citizenship questions at the commencement and not to operate prospectively, which was later governed by parliamentary legislation under Article 11.
- If Sohan’s monthly salary is (75/3)% more than Rohan’s salary, then by what percentage is Rohan’s salary less than Sohan’s?
- The incomes of Arjun, Kabir, and Lakshya are in the ratio 15:10:9, and their savings are in the ratio 6:4:3. If Kabir saves Rs. 16,000, which is 40% of his...
The monthly incomes of A and B are in the ratio 3 : 4, and their monthly expenditures are in the ratio 2 : 3. If each of them saves Rs. 4,000 per month,...
The income of P is 3/4 th of the income of Q and income of R is 70% more than the income of Q. Income of Q is Rs.24000 and expenditure of P ...
- The income of Kavita is (50/2)% more than the income of Sneha. How much percent less is Sneha’s income compared to Kavita’s?
Person X's earnings exceed Person Y's by 25%, and both individuals manage to save Rs. 2400 each. The ratio of Person Y's expenses to Person X's expenses...
- The salary of a person is increased by Rs. 500. If his old salary was 25% less than his new salary, then his old salary was:
- X allocates his monthly income as follows: 10% for rent, 20% for groceries, and 25% for bills, while saving the remaining amount. If his savings amount to ...
Priya spends 35% of her income on house rent. From what’s left, she uses 25% for groceries and 50% for travel. The rest is her savings. If the differe...
Average income of 'X' and 'Y' together is Rs. 45,000. Whereas the average expenditure of 'X' and 'Y' is Rs. 34,000. Find the savi...