πŸ“’ Too many exams? Don’t know which one suits you best? Book Your Free Expert πŸ‘‰ call Now!

  • google app store apple app store
  • βœ–

      Question

      Under Section 14 of the Industrial Relations Code, 2020,

      the Act introduces the statutory framework for recognising a Sole Negotiating Union or a Negotiating Council. Which of the following correctly describes all three scenarios single union, multiple unions, and no eligible union?
      A Single union: automatic recognition regardless of membership; multiple unions: union with 75% membership recognised; no eligible union: government nominates a union Correct Answer Incorrect Answer
      B Single union: recognised with 51% membership; multiple unions: union with 75% membership; no eligible union: Central Government refers the dispute to the National Industrial Tribunal Correct Answer Incorrect Answer
      C Single union: recognised only after 5 years of existence; multiple unions: union with 40% membership; no eligible union: employer may directly negotiate with worker representatives Correct Answer Incorrect Answer
      D Single union: recognised as sole negotiating union if it has at least 30% of total workers as members; multiple unions: union with 51% or more workers on muster roll recognised as sole negotiating union; no union meets 51% threshold: a Negotiating Council is formed consisting of representatives of all unions having at least 20% of workers as members Correct Answer Incorrect Answer

      Solution

      Section 14 of the Industrial Relations Code, 2020 creates a three-tier recognition framework based on the number of registered trade unions operating in an establishment. First, where only one registered trade union functions in the establishment, the employer must recognise it as the Sole Negotiating Union but the Draft Rules prescribe a minimum membership of 30% of total workers, borrowed from the Maharashtra model, to prevent a tiny union from claiming exclusive negotiating rights. Second, where multiple registered unions function, the union demonstrating support of 51% or more of workers on the muster roll is recognised as the Sole Negotiating Union this majority threshold ensures true democratic representativeness. Third, if no union achieves 51%, a Negotiating Council is constituted comprising representatives of all unions that have at least 20% of workers as members raised from the 10% threshold in the 2019 Bill to prevent fragmentation. Crucially, under Section 14(6), any recognition granted or Negotiating Council constituted is valid for a fixed tenure of 3 years, extendable up to 5 years by mutual agreement a stabilising reform that prevents perpetual re-contestation of union recognition.

      Practice Next
      ask-question